Friday, four o'clock. Nadia is finishing the report promised for Monday when her manager leans round the door. “Could you also take over the Martin file? It's urgent.” She says yes before she has even thought about it.
Her weekend will go on it. On Monday the report will be late and the Martin file half done. The yes that was meant to please will end up disappointing twice.
Saying no to your manager puts your career at risk.
A series of experiments published in 2023 shows that we clearly overestimate the consequences of saying no. People who are turned down take it far less badly than those refusing imagine. The study looked at invitations rather than work, but the fear it describes is the same.2
In Julian Givi and Colleen Kirk's study, 77% of participants said they had already accepted an invitation they did not want, for fear of the consequences of saying no.2
The right to say no
Assertiveness has been studied since the 1950s, notably by psychiatrist Joseph Wolpe. Robert Alberti and Michael Emmons popularised it in 1970 in a book with a telling title, Your Perfect Right.1
In 1975, Manuel J. Smith published When I Say No, I Feel Guilty. The title alone sums up what many people still feel at work.1
Two habits to start with
Take a moment before answering
A reflex yes commits you to more than it seems. Asking for a few minutes to check what you have on lets you answer with full knowledge.
“Let me check what I have on and I'll come back to you in ten minutes.”
Ask about priorities
When everything is urgent, asking what comes first puts the decision back with the person who sets the priorities.
“If I take this file, which of the two should wait?”
Saying yes is sometimes the wisest choice, for reasons only you know, your position, the timing or the relationship. Some requests also fall under your contract and are not open to discussion.
You are best placed to judge whether a refusal is fair and sustainable. If requests become excessive or keep coming, talking to someone you trust or to HR may help.
Saying no without closing the door can be learned
These two habits give you some breathing room. They do not tell you how to word a clear refusal, or how to hold your position when someone insists. The Assertiveness module goes further.
- Making a clear request, without beating about the bush or being aggressive.
- Saying no without closing the door.
- Holding your position when the pressure rises.
This edition presents one approach among others, for information only. It is not legal advice, HR advice or personal coaching.