OFF THESYLLABUS
TheOff the SyllabusGazette
Edition
No. 5
The Question Gazette · Thinking

How do you spot dubious information before sharing it?

A shocking figure is going round the company, and no one knows where it comes from.A question many people ask

4 min read2 sourcesCritical thinking module

Wednesday, on the team chat. A colleague shares an article claiming that 80% of customers leave a brand after a single bad experience. Within an hour, the figure has made it into three presentations.

Nobody opened the source. The day a client asks where the figure comes from, the meeting suddenly goes very quiet.

The common belief

Information that looks professional, with figures and a serious logo, must be reliable.

What research shows

In 2017, Stanford researchers compared historians, students and professional fact-checkers. The first two groups trusted the look of a website, its logos and its references. The fact-checkers quickly left the page to see what other sources said about it.2

70%

In a study published in Science in 2018, covering some 126,000 rumours spread on Twitter between 2006 and 2017, false news was 70% more likely to be shared than true news.1

Reading sideways

MIT researchers Soroush Vosoughi, Deb Roy and Sinan Aral showed that falsehood travels farther, faster and more widely than the truth.1

Sam Wineburg and Sarah McGrew described a habit of professional fact-checkers they call lateral reading. Rather than scrutinising a page, these professionals open other tabs to find out who is behind it.2

Two habits to start with

Go back to the source

Before sharing a figure, look for who produced it, when and how. If it is impossible to tell, that already tells you something.

“Do you have the link to the original study?”

Be wary of what suits you too well

Information that confirms exactly what you already thought deserves a second look, precisely because you want to believe it.

Nobody has time to check everything, and it is not always necessary. A figure thrown into a conversation does not carry the same weight as one that will be used to make a decision.

You are best placed to judge how much checking a situation deserves, and when it is better to ask a question than to pass something on.

What stays off the syllabus

Telling facts from opinions can be learned

These two habits avoid the most obvious mistakes. They do not tell you how to take apart an appealing argument, or how to judge a source when everything looks credible. The Critical thinking module goes further.

  • Telling a fact from an opinion, however well presented.
  • Judging how reliable a source is in a few minutes.
  • Spotting the flaw in an argument that seems solid.
Critical thinkingThinking · 14 steps · exam and certificate
€29Or 7 modules of your choice for €149
Discover the module →

Was this edition useful to you?